History of NIC Boys Soccer
Soccer became an IHSAA sport in 1994-95 and an NIC sport. NISL governed high school soccer before the IHSAA adoption.
- 1994-95 – SB Adams IHSAA State Runner-Up with Coach Jim Tallman
- 1999-00 – Penn IHSAA State Champions with Coach Tony Bauman
- 2003-04 – SB St. Joseph IHSAA State Champions with Coach Leroy Krempec
- 2006-07 – Elkhart Central IHSAA State Runner-Up with Coach Ryan Leniski
- 2015-16 – Marian IHSAA 1A State Champions with Coach Ben Householter
- 2016-17 – Marian IHSAA 1A State Champions with Coach Ben Householter
- 2019-20 – SB St. Joseph IHSAA 2A State Runner-Up with Coach Alberto Verteramo
- 2021-22 – Marian IHSAA 2A State Runner-Up with Coach Ben Householter
- 2022-23 – Marian IHSAA 2A State Runner-Up with Coach Ben Householter
- 2023-24 – Marian IHSAA 2A State Champions with Coach Ben Householter
| Year | Champion-School | Record | Coach | MVP | Coach of the Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1994-95 | Elkhart Central | 7-0-1 | Dale Stoltzfus | Adam Kowalski of SB Clay | Dale Stoltzfus of Elkhart Central |
| 1995-96 | Elkhart Central | 7-1 | Dale Stoltzfus | Jeff Krempec of SB Clay | Dale Stoltzfus of Elkhart Central |
| 1996-97 | Elkhart Central | 7-1 | Dale Stoltzfus | Justin Hines of SB Clay | Tony Bauman of Penn |
| Penn | 7-1 | Tony Bauman | |||
| 1997-98 | Elkhart Central | 7-0-1 | Dale Stoltzfus | Armando Femia of SB Adams | Dale Stoltzfus of Elkhart Central |
| 1998-99 | Elkhart Central | 7-0-1 | Dale Stoltzfus | Mike Erikson of Penn | Tony Bauman of Penn |
| Penn | 7-0-1 | Tony Bauman | |||
| 1999-00 | Penn | 7-0-1 | Tony Bauman | Mike Erikson of Penn | George Lund of SB Clay |
| 2000-01 | Penn | 7-0 | Tony Bauman | Matt Parrott of Penn | Dennis Jay of Mishawaka |
| 2001-02 | SB Clay | 5-0-2 | George Lund | Adam Ponder of SB Clay | Ryan Leniski of Elkhart Central |
| 2002-03 | Penn | 4-0-2 | Steve Dregits | Richard Trejo of SB Adams | Ryan Leniski of Elkhart Central |
| 2003-04 | Elkhart Central | 5-0-1 | Ryan Leniski | Brian Huss of Elkhart Central | Ryan Leniski of Elkhart Central |
| 2004-05 | Elkhart Central | 8-0 | Ryan Leniski | Ted Moskwinski of SB St. Joseph | Ryan Leniski of Elkhart Central |
| 2005-06 | Elkhart Central | 8-0 | Ryan Leniski | Dustin Mares of SB St. Joseph | Ryan Leniski of Elkhart Central |
| 2006-07 | Elkhart Central | 8-0 | Ryan Leniski | Alec Purdie of Elkhart Central | Dan Deeter of SB Adams |
| 2007-08 | Marian | 8-0 | Ben Householder | Tommy Blum of Marian | Ben Householder of Marian |
| 2008-09 | Penn | 7-1 | Larry McClements | Austin Hiatt of Penn | Larry McClements of Penn |
| 2009-10 | Penn | 8-0 | Larry McClements | Eric Walker of Penn | Larry McClements of Penn |
| 2010-11 | Penn | 8-0 | Larry McClements | Tim Wilson of Penn | Cruz Gallegos of SB Riley |
| 2011-12 | Penn | 7-1 | Ryan Leniski | Daniel Stump of Penn | Ryan Leniski of Penn |
| 2012-13 | Elkhart Central | 8-0 | Sherwin Simon | Isaias Morales of Elkhart Central | Sherwin Simon of Elkhart Central |
| 2013-14 | Penn | 7-1 | Ryan Leniski | Tommy Clark of SB St. Joseph | Jim Brugh of Mishawaka |
| Elkhart Central | 7-1 | Sherwin Simon | |||
| 2014-15 | Marian | 8-0 | Ben Householter | Alex Ramirez of Elkhart Central | Ben Householter of Marian |
| 2015-16 | Marian | 9-1 | Ben Householter | Ben Householter of Marian | |
| Elkhart Central | 9-1 | Sherwin Simon | Javier Vera of Elkhart Central | ||
| 2016-17 | Penn | 10-0 | Joshua Nakayama | Louis Nanni of SB St. Joseph | Joshua Nakayama of Penn |
| 2017-18 | Marian | 10-0 | Ben Householter | Jonathan Tavarez of Marian | Ben Householter of Marian |
| 2018-19 | SB St. Joseph | 4-0 North | Alberto Verteramo | JP Raster of SB St. Joseph | Alberto Verteramo of SB St. Joseph |
| SB Washington | 5-0 South | Lorenzo Garcia | Ricardo Alvarez of SB Washington | Lorenzo Garcia of SB Washington | |
| 2019-20 | SB St. Joseph | 3-1 North | Alberto Verteramo | ||
| Penn | 3-1 North | Kyle Zaber | Michael Baughman of Marian | Ben Householter of Marian | |
| Marian | 3-1 North | Ben Householter | |||
| Bremen | 5-0 South | Mark Yoder | Collin Moren of Bremen | Mark Yoder of Bremen | |
| 2020-21 | Penn | 3-1 E-W | Kyle Zaber | David Ross of Penn | Todd Sheely of Elkhart |
| Bremen | 5-0 N-S | Mark Yoder | Samuel Thomas of Glenn | Ivan Castillo of SB Washington | |
| 2021-22 | Penn | 3-1 E-W | Kyle Zaber | Dalton Blakenbaker of Penn | Kyle Zaber of Penn |
| Bremen | 5-0 N-S | Mark Yoder | Alex Alvardo of Bremen | Mark Yoder of Bremen | |
| 2022-23 | Marian | 4-0 E-W | Ben Householter | Jaxson Hundt of Marian | Ben Householter of Marian |
| Bremen | 5-0 N-S | Mark Yoder | Hudson Fox of Bremen | Daniel Reffo of New Prairie | |
| 2023-24 | Marian | 4-0 E-W | Ben Householter | Eli Moody of Marian | Ben Householter of Marian |
| Bremen | 5-0 N-S | Mark Yoder | Hudson Fox of Bremen | Jon Boye of SB Riley | |
| 2024-25 | Penn | 6-1 | Kyle Zaber | Chris Miller of Penn | Cristian Mihut of SB Adams |
| 2025-26 | Elkhart | 6-1 | Todd Sheely | Miguel Gallegos of Elkhart | Tood Sheely of Elkhart & |
| Cristian Mihut of SB Adams |