History of NIC Girls Soccer
Soccer became an IHSAA sport in 1994-95 as well as an NIC sport. NISL governed high school soccer before the IHSAA adoption.
- 2003-04 – SB St. Joseph State Runner-Ups with Coach Johan Kuitse
- 2007-08 – Penn State Runner-Ups with Coach Mike Luber
- 2010-11 – SB St. Joseph State Champions with Coach Johan Kuitse
- 2011-12 – Marian 1A State Champions with Coach Djamel Charmat
- 2011-12 – SB St. Joseph 2A State Runner-Ups with Coach Johan Kuitse
- 2015-16 – Penn 2A State Runner-Ups with Coach Jeff Hart
- 2016-17 – Penn 2A State Champions with Coach Jeff Hart
- 2017-18 – SB St. Joseph 2A State Runner-Ups with Coach Phil DePauw
- 2017-18 – Penn 3A State Champions with Coach Jeff Hart
- 2018-19 – SB St. Joseph 2A State Runner-Ups with Coach Phil DePauw
- 2021-22 – Marian 2A State Runner-ups with Coach Henry Vu
- 2025-26 – Marian 2A State Champions with Coach Henry Vu
| Year | Champion | Record | Coach | MVP | Coach of the Year |
| 1994-95 | Penn | 8-0 | Tom VanMeter | Heather Jones of SB Adams | Tom VanMeter of Penn |
| 1995-96 | SB Adams | 8-0 | Caryn MacKenzie | Stephanie Wrass of SB Clay | Tom VanMeter of Penn |
| 1996-97 | SB Adams | 7-1 | Caryn MacKenzie | Lindsey Jones of SB Adams | Steve Crawford of Mishawaka |
| 1997-98 | SB Adams | 8-0 | Caryn MacKenzie | Lindsey Jones of SB Adams | Caryn MacKenzie of SB Adams |
| 1998-99 | Penn | 8-0 | Tom VanMeter | Erin Poe of SB Clay | Tom VanMeter of Penn |
| 1999-00 | SB Clay | 7-1 | Ron Zielinski | Erin Poe of SB Clay | Caryn MacKenzie of SB Adams |
| SB Adams | 7-1 | Caryn MacKenzie | |||
| 2000-01 | Penn | 6-0-1 | Tom VanMeter | Bethany Keuper of SB Adams | Kerry Wilson of Mishawaka |
| 2001-02 | SB Adams | 7-0 | Caryn MacKenzie | Chelsea Ferrie of Penn | Caryn MacKenzie of SB Adams |
| 2002-03 | SB Adams | 5-0-1 | Caryn MacKenzie | Korin Maciulski of SB Adams | Kerry Wilson of Mishawaka |
| 2003-04 | Penn | 6-0 | Tom VanMeter | Mary Whisler of Elkhart Central | Eric Jantzen of Elkhart Central |
| 2004-05 | Penn | 8-0 | Tom VanMeter | Annie Aiello of Penn | Tom VanMeter of Penn |
| 2005-06 | Marian | 7-1 | Carlos Reynolds | Jackie Kondratko of Penn | Mary Lahey of SB Washington |
| Penn | 7-1 | Mike Luber | |||
| SB St. Joseph | 7-1 | Johan Kuitse | |||
| 2006-07 | Marian | 7-1 | Carlos Reynolds | Rachel Byron of Marian | Carlos Reynolds of Marian |
| Penn | 7-1 | Mike Luber | |||
| SB St. Joseph | 7-1 | Johan Kuitse | |||
| 2007-08 | Penn | 7-1 | Mike Luber | Mary Adams of SB Clay | Paul Kingston of SB Clay |
| SB Clay | 7-1 | Paul Kingston | |||
| SB St. Joseph | 7-1 | Johan Kuitse | |||
| 2008-09 | Penn | 8-0 | Mike Luber | Leeann Kuehn of Penn | Carlos Reynolds of Marian |
| 2009-10 | SB St. Joseph | 8-0 | Johan Kuitse | Tayler Turner of SB St. Joseph | Johan Kuitse of SB St. Joseph |
| 2010-11 | SB St. Joseph | 8-0 | Johan Kuitse | Sarah Hall of SB St. Joseph | Johan Kuitse of SB St. Joseph |
| 2011-12 | SB St. Joseph | 8-0 | Johan Kuitse | Gabby Veldman of Marian | Djamel Charmat of Marian |
| 2012-13 | Marian | 7-1 | Djamel Charmat | Catherine Raster of SB St. Joseph | Chris Mallott of Elkhart Central |
| Penn | 7-1 | Jeff Hart | |||
| SB St. Joseph | 7-1 | Johan Kuitse | |||
| 2013-14 | SB St. Joseph | 8-0 | Johan Kuitse | Madison Turner of SB St. Joseph | Johan Kuitse of SB St. Joseph |
| 2014-15 | Marian | 7-1 | Djamel Charmat | Shannon Hendricks of Marian | Jeff Hart of Penn |
| Penn | 7-1 | Jeff Hart | |||
| SB St. Joseph | 7-1 | Johan Kuitse | |||
| 2015-16 | Penn | 10-0 | Jeff Hart | Sam Kambol of SB St. Joseph | Jeff Hart of Penn |
| 2016-17 | Penn | 10-0 | Jeff Hart | Kristina Lynch of Penn | Jeff Hart of Penn & Caryn MacKenzie of SB Adams |
| 2017-18 | Penn | 10-0 | Jeff Hart | Kristina Lynch of Penn | Jeff Hart of Penn |
| 2018-19 | Penn | 4-0 North | Jeff Hart | Maya Lacognato of Penn | Jeff Hart of Penn |
| Bremen | 4-1 South | Natasha Flores | Wendy Nava of Bremen | Natasha Flores of Bremen | |
| Glenn | 4-1 South | Bobbie Milliken | |||
| Mishawaka | 4-1 South | Steve Hodge | |||
| 2019-20 | SB St. Joseph | 4-0 North | Phil DePauw | Sydney Egendoerfer of Penn | Phil DePauw of SB St. Joseph |
| Glenn | 5-0 South | Bobbie Milliken | Rachel Gomez of Mishawaka | Bobbie Milliken of Glenn | |
| 2020-21 | SB St. Joseph | 3-1 E-W | Phil DePauw | Georgia Place of SB St. Joseph | Phil DePauw of SB St. Joseph |
| Genn | 5-1 N-S | Bobbie Milliken | Seja Lang of Glenn | Bobbie Milliken of Glenn | |
| 2021-22 | SB St. Joseph | 4-0 E-W | Phil DePauw | Ella Frick of SB St. Joseph | Phil DePauw of SB St. Joseph |
| Glenn | 6-0 N-S | Bobbie Milliken | Luna Thomas of Glenn | Bobbie Milliken of Glenn | |
| 2022-23 | Marian | 4-0 E-W | Henry Vu | Ella Frick of SB St. Joseph | Henry Vu of Marian |
| Glenn | 5-0 N-S | Bobbie Milliken | Lanie Day of Glenn & Kamille Liddell of SB Riley | Bobbie Milliken of Glenn | |
| 2023-24 | SB St. Joseph | 4-0 E-W | Phil DePauw | Meg Baxter of SB St. Joseph | Phil DePauw of SB St. Joseph |
| Glenn | 5-0 N-S | Bobbie Milliken | Hannah Thomas of Glenn | Moises Fairchild of Jimtown | |
| 2024-25 | Penn | 5-1 | Jeff Hart | Anika Guenther of Penn | Henry Vu of Marian & Ryan Yazel of SB Adams |
| 2025-26 | Penn | 6-0 | Jeff Hart | Natalia Garcia-Souffront of Penn | Jeff Hart of Penn |